Australia Markets closed

Captain 'Sully' Sullenberger has a message for Boeing about its 737 Max

Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger, the decorated commercial airline captain responsible for saving the lives of 155 people in a heroic 2009 landing on New York’s Hudson River, has a message for Boeing (BA) and the Federal Aviation Administration: pilots need robust training before the 737 Max returns to the skies.

“Reading about it on an iPad isn't even close to sufficient,” Sullenberger testified during a congressional subcommittee hearing on Wednesday. He asserted that recertification should require simulator training, which subjects pilots to conditions that closely emulate those in flight.

“We should all want pilots to experience these challenging situations for the first time in a simulator and not in flight with passengers and crew on board,” Sullenberger said.

More time and costs before the Max can fly?

Exactly how much and what type of pilot training is needed before Boeing’s Max can be re-certified by the FAA and returned to service has been a topic of debate, as some aviation experts point to a lack of sufficient training concerning the Max systems as a central cause in the cascade of events that led to two fatal Max aircraft crashes within five months. Meanwhile, others claim more experienced pilots would have averted crisis. Simulator training, estimated to cost hundreds of dollars per hour, if required by the FAA, will add time and cost to the Max’s return to flight.

“We must face [the emergency] first-hand in a simulator before we experience it in flight,” Sullenberger told lawmakers.

As a result of the crashes, Boeing agreed to modify all Max planes in order to feed additional sensor data into a system designed for the aircraft called MCAS, or Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System. The system, which automatically pushes the nose of the plane down to prevent engine stall, is known to have been activated in both the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes that killed all passengers and crew on board.

UNITED STATES - JANUARY 16: Front page of the Daily News for January 16, 2009, headline reads: Hero of the Hudson, Pilot saves 155 as he lands jet in frigid New York river., photo of pilot Chesley Sullenberger (Photo by NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)

The importance of the ‘startle factor’

Throughout his testimony, Sullenberger emphasized the significance of pilot “startle factor” and chaotic cockpit situations that play into a pilot’s emergency response capabilities.

Asked by Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY) whether more experienced pilots would have been able to handle the MCAS-related emergencies, Sullenberger opined that it would have been unlikely they would have performed differently than the crews on the accident flights.

“I'm one of a relatively small group of people who have experienced such a crisis and lived to share what we learned about it. I can tell you firsthand that the startle factor is real. And it's huge. It absolutely interferes with one's ability to quickly analyze the crisis and take an active action,” Sullenberger said. “In both 737 max accidents, the failure of a single angle of attack sensor quickly caused multiple instrument indication anomalies, and sudden, loud, and in some cases, false warnings, creating major distractions masking the cause, and would have made it even harder to quickly analyze the situation and take effective, corrective action.”

Captain Dan Carey, Allied Pilots Association president and veteran commercial aircraft pilot, seconded Sullenberg’s position.

“This is a sudden, violent, and terrifying event,” Carey testified. “So airplanes pitching up and down rapidly and violently. There's bells, warnings, and clappers sounding. Communication is difficult.”

Carey blamed Boeing for prioritizing costs over safety.

“The Max was designed to provide the same aircraft feel as the 737. This was intended to minimize costs to Boeing's customers by allowing the Max to be certified as a 737-type aircraft. This led Boeing engineers to add the MCAS system,” he said. “Boeing failed to disclose the existence of the MCAS system to the pilot community around the world. The final fatal mistake was therefore the absence of a robust pilot training in the event of an MCAS failure.”

Boeing CEO Dennis Muilenburg has suggested a less aggressive approach than simulator training.

“We believe that the right answer right now is computer-based training,” Muilenberg told shareholders during Boeing’s annual meeting in April. “And then as part of the recurring training that pilots might do downstream, give them options for simulator training.”

Ultimately, the decision on requisite training rests with FAA regulators.

In response to whether Boeing’s position on flight training had changed since Muilenberg’s statement in April, a company spokesperson told Yahoo Finance, “Boeing continues to work with global regulators and our airline customers as they determine training requirements.”

Regarding the timeline for the Max to return to service, Boeing’s spokesperson said, “We have not given a timeline — safety is our priority and is the primary driver in the process. We have finalized the software update and the next step will be to finish certification work in the simulators ahead of the certification test flights, which will be scheduled with the FAA.”

Read more:

‘These kids never consented’: Why Amazon is being sued over Alexa recordings

Why the media is blaming Facebook and Google for its decline

‘The full Willy Wonky Tour’: Inside Weed company Cresco’s production house

GOP Senator has ‘pretty good confidence’ Congress will pass weed legislation

These are the biggest threats to the cannabis industry, according to top CEOs in the space

Why the world’s largest marijuana company is doubling its plans for US hemp

Alexis Keenan is a New York-based reporter for Yahoo Finance. She previously produced and reported for CNN and is a former litigation attorney. Follow on Twitter @alexiskweed.

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, SmartNews, LinkedIn,YouTube, and reddit.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Friday, January 17.

  • ASX records new high for fourth day in row
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    ASX records new high for fourth day in row

    The Australian share market has pushed through to new all-time highs for a fourth day in a row, with mining stocks leading the way this time.

  • Sydney's SiteMinder latest Aussie unicorn
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Sydney's SiteMinder latest Aussie unicorn

    Hotel inventory management platform SiteMinder has finished a funding round that values the Sydney-based company at $1.1 billion.

  • Sezzle fined, gets Calif. lending licence
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Sezzle fined, gets Calif. lending licence

    ASX-listed buy now, pay later company Sezzle will get its California lending licence after agreeing to pay $450,000 in fines and refunds.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    AAP Markets report for Friday, Jan 17

    Movements on overseas markets.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Thursday, January 16.

  • History made as ASX200 surges past 7,000
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    History made as ASX200 surges past 7,000

    The ASX200 has shattered the landmark 7,000 level for the first time, pushing to new highs for a third straight day after the US and China signed a trade deal.

  • Noxopharm spin-off Nyrada floats on ASX
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Noxopharm spin-off Nyrada floats on ASX

    Sydney biotech company Nyrada has made its debut on the ASX in the first float of the year following an $8.5 million initial public offering.

  • Caltex opening the books for Couche-Tard
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Caltex opening the books for Couche-Tard

    Caltex Australia says it will open its books for Canada's Alimentation Couche-Tard as it manoeuvre to get a better price than ACT's $8.6 billion takeover offer.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    AAP Markets report for Thursday, Jan 16

    Movements on overseas markets.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Wednesday, January 15.

  • Jeanswest collapse threatens 1000 jobs
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Jeanswest collapse threatens 1000 jobs

    The collapse of clothing chain Jeanswest puts nearly 1000 jobs at risk as the retailer becomes the latest Australian brand to fall to low consumer spending.

  • ASX200 gains, closes just under 7,000
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    ASX200 gains, closes just under 7,000

    The Australian share market has finished just 5.2 points from the 7,000 mark ahead of the signing of a key trade deal between the US and China.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    AAP Markets report for Wednesday, Jan 15

    Movements on overseas markets.

  • 'Stellar day' as ASX surges to fresh high
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    'Stellar day' as ASX surges to fresh high

    Surging investor optimism ahead of a looming US-China trade deal has helped propel Australian share prices to another all-time high.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Tuesday, January 14.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    AAP Markets report for Tuesday, Jan 14

    Movements on overseas markets.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Monday, January 13.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    ASX pulls back after days of strong gains

    The Australian share market has dipped at the start of the week's trade, with tech and property stocks the only sectors to gain ground.

  • Bushfires could deliver 0.5% hit to GDP
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Bushfires could deliver 0.5% hit to GDP

    Westpac has attempted to tally the economic damage of the raging bushfires, forecasting they could cost the economy $5 billion in direct losses.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    AAP Markets report for Monday, Jan 13

    Movements on overseas markets.

  • ASX expected to fall after record week
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    ASX expected to fall after record week

    The Australian share market is expected to open lower in the wake of falls on Wall Street at the end of last week.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Wall St edges down after recent records

    Investors taking profits after record highs this week and data showing slower-than-expected December US jobs growth have helped prompt US stocks to slip..

  • Stocks higher as Middle East tensions ease
    Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks higher as Middle East tensions ease

    Investors cheered an apparent de-escalation in US-Iran tensions and looked instead to prospects of improved global growth, sending world stocks to record highs.

  • Finance
    Australian Associated Press

    Stocks to watch

    Stocks of interest at the close of trading on Friday, January 10.