Advertisement
Australia markets open in 7 hours 31 minutes
  • ALL ORDS

    8,010.50
    -5.30 (-0.07%)
     
  • AUD/USD

    0.6674
    +0.0016 (+0.23%)
     
  • ASX 200

    7,769.70
    -8.40 (-0.11%)
     
  • OIL

    81.57
    0.00 (0.00%)
     
  • GOLD

    2,345.40
    -1.50 (-0.06%)
     
  • Bitcoin AUD

    97,345.44
    +723.24 (+0.75%)
     
  • CMC Crypto 200

    1,378.24
    +40.49 (+3.03%)
     

Tory manifesto: pledge to revive Help to Buy scheme 'devoid of imagination' say property experts

Rishi Sunak launches the Conservative manifesto at Silverstone (James Manning/PA) (PA Wire)
Rishi Sunak launches the Conservative manifesto at Silverstone (James Manning/PA) (PA Wire)

The Conservative’s would resurrect Help to Buy if they win the general election, according to the party’s 2024 manifesto.

This relaunched scheme would “provide first-time buyers with an equity loan of up to 20 per cent towards the cost of a new build home” with a five per cent deposit on “interest terms they can afford”.

The scheme would be “part funded by contributions from house builders”.

Conservative’s set their homebuilding goal at 1.6 million over the next parliament, in a bid to outdo Labour’s promise of 1.5 million new homes.

Help to Buy reloaded

Help to Buy originally launched in 2013 under then-chancellor George Osborne.

ADVERTISEMENT

It offered a five-year interest-free loan of 20 per cent of the property value if first-time buyers put down a five per cent deposit.

The scheme, which only applied to new-build homes, was updated in 2016 to include London Help to Buy with a 40 per cent interest-free loan on a property up to £600,000

It was extended several times before it finally ended on 31 March 2023.

Simon Gerrard, Managing Director of Martyn Gerrard Estate Agents, said the manifesto demonstrated that the governing party was “devoid of imagination” and “out of ideas”.

“Reviving Help to Buy is a good idea — but it is ultimately meaningless if there are no homes to buy,” said Gerrard.

“Lowering the loan-to-value and purchase thresholds in London from £450,000 to £400,000 this time is perplexing given how much property prices have appreciated since the last scheme was launched. Offering watered-down, rehashed versions of previous policies is not going to solve the crisis we face.”

The average London house price currently sits at £499,663. First-time buyers using the Government’s Lifetime ISA scheme to save up for a deposit mustn’t go above a £450,000 cap on house price or they lose their bonus plus interest.

Help to Buy has been accused of driving up property prices in the capital, as housebuilders set their prices as close as possible to the £600,000 threshold. This new build premium also put buyers at risk of negative equity.

City Hall reported last year that 4,500 Londoners are struggling to repay their Help to Buy loans as rising interest rates squeezed homeowners.

Stamp duty scrapped — for some

The Conservatives also promised to help first-time buyers by permanently scrapping Stamp Duty for first homes under £425,000.

Currently first-time buyers pay zero stamp duty on homes up to £425,000 and five per cent on the portion between £425,001 to £625,000, although this was due to end in 2025.

“This isn’t a bad idea, but it simply doesn’t go far enough,” said Gerrard.

“The Stamp Duty system in the country isn’t fit for purpose by preventing transactions, jamming the market and disincentivising older people from downsizing homes,” he added.

“If the Government reformed stamp duty to encourage downsizers, then there would be more properties suitable for young families on the market, which are also desperately needed. The tax needs a complete revamp not more tinkering around the sides.”

Ban on section 21 (again)

Despite failing to get the Renters Reform Bill through Parliament since the last general election, the manifesto has promised to “deliver fairness in the rental market for landlords and renters alike” with another go-round of the Bill.

Section 21’s are so-called no-fault evictions where tenants can be served two months without the landlord having to provide a reason.

The Bill stumbled as landlords protested that the ban would put their property investments at risk.

“We will deliver the court reforms necessary to fully abolish Section 21 and strengthen other grounds for landlords to evict private tenants guilty of anti-social behaviour,” said the Conservative manifesto.

Ben Beadle, chief executive of the National Residential Landlords Association (NRLA), said it wasn’t enough.

“Reform of the rental market should have taken place in the last Parliament,” said .

“As we said then, a balance between security for tenants and policies which retain the confidence of responsible landlords is crucial if we are to deliver much-needed homes for rent.”

Nearly 26,000 households were threatened with homelessness through no-fault evictions in 2023, the highest annual figure ever recorded.

Tax relief for landlords

One new idea for housing in the manifesto was a tax cut for landlords who sell their house to their tenants.

“To further support homeowners, we will introduce a two-year temporary Capital Gains Tax relief for landlords who sell to their existing tenants,” read the manifesto.

This could address the issue of tenants being made homeless when their landlords sells up — if tenants could afford the house after years of paying rent over saving for a deposit.

Graham Boar, Partner at accountancy group UHY Hacker Young warned this could create a loophole that’s “ripe for abuse”.

“There’s a risk that landlords selling properties will structure them as tenancies leading to sales, avoiding huge amounts of Capital Gains Tax,” said Boar.

“A landlord could also sell a property ‘on credit’ to a tenant, who could then sell it on with no gain and pay back their debt to the landlord. Either way, HMRC would miss out on huge amounts of tax.”

HMRC raised £1.7 million in Capital Gains Tax from the sale of second or further homes, most of which came from buy-to-let landlords.

“Tenants who want to become homeowners should be supported to do so,” said Beadle.

“Whilst incentivising landlords to sell to existing tenants has the potential to help, it will not reverse the damage to the rental market caused by tax hikes under recent Conservative governments.”

Nothing on non-doms

There was no mention in the manifesto on the tax regime changes for non-UK domiciled individuals — aka non-doms. Overseas investors are reportedly waiting to see which way the election goes before buying a home in London, causing prime property prices to stumble.

"Despite the Chancellor's announcement on 6 March to abolish the UK's non-dom regime, the Conservative manifesto is surprisingly silent on the topic, with no further information of when the changes might be introduced,” said Carol Katz, partner in Mishcon de Reya Private’s tax and wealth planning group.

“Labour's manifesto may include more detail on their proposals, and we await its publication with interest."

The full Labour manifesto is expected to by published this week.