Australia markets closed

The real reason we're seeing a property market slowdown

The property boom we recently experienced in Sydney and Melbourne ended about a year ago.

Initially the Sydney market started to fizzle out (it’s down -4.5% over the last year) and now Melbourne’s housing market has stalled (down -1.4% over the last quarter, but still + 1% over the last 12 months).

Also read: Why SMSF’s could start a property market crash

Remember the headlines not that long ago?

Sky high auction clearance rates and fear of missing out pushing up prices of any property that was put on the market.

But how does this compare to previous property booms?

Also read: What to do if your shares rocket

Earlier this year CoreLogic dissected our housing cycle over the past twenty years into  five year increments which revealed some interesting facts.

Firstly, comparing the last 5 years with previous market cycles showed that the increase in property rises we experienced were not as strong as some markets delivered in previous periods.

While Sydney’s property values increased 64.4% over the 5 years to January 2018 and Melbourne dwelling prices increased 56.4% in the same period, the graphs below will show you how certain markets eclipsed these rates of growth in past cycles.

Some other trends

The following charts show that over the last two decades each region had its turn in the sun.

They also show that at some point in every cycle it was easy to find a reason why property values would stop rising, but looking back over the last 20 years a couple of trends stood out:-

  • Dwelling values have increased by 231% nationally
  • Capital growth in our combined capital cities (+252%) outperformed the combined regional markets (+167%)
  • Melbourne was the strongest property market over the last 20 years (+335%)

Also read: Is the price of iron ore about to crash? 

Let’s delve deeper into these 5-year periods:

January 1998 to January 2003

We experienced a housing boom at the turn of the century, but I clearly remember that when GST was introduced by the Howard government in July 2001 many commentators suggested this would decimate the construction industry and stall our housing markets as new homes and apartments would become disproportionately more expensive than established properties which carried no GST.

However nationally house prices rose 61.9% over those 5 years with capital city growth out performing regional Australia, yet regional NSW grew 84.1% topping the grow charts.

After a number of years of strong growth in the late 90’s the Sydney property market moved into its slump and underperformed for a number of years.

Yardney 30/07/18

Source: Corelogic

January 2003 to January 2008

The next 5 years were the early stages of Australia’s great infrastructure and mining boom causing property values to explode in areas related to the resources sector.

Dwelling values more than doubled in regional Western Australia (120.7%) as well as in Perth (102.0%) where house prices were almost as expensive as in Sydney.

Also read: 9 easy ways to avoid failure

As you can see form the graph below, regional property markets outperformed capital city markets during this 5 year period.

But no one could see the impending Global Financial Crisis that was going to change everything, as the seeds were being sown by the looming subprime loan crisis in the USA.

Yardney 30/07/18

Source: Corelogic

January 2008 to January 2013

The GFC influenced this 5 year period of low growth of Australian house prices, but despite the worst world economic downturn since the great depression, government intervention with low interest rates and first home owner grants buoyed our housing markets.

Also read: How one woman saved enough on her grocery shop to send her family on a cruise every year

Darwin (+31.8%) and regional NT (+38.1%) were the strongest markets in this period fuelled by our mining boom.

Yardney 30/07/18

Source: Corelogic 

January 2013 to January 2018

Despite their falls over recent months, the Sydney (+64.4%) and Melbourne property markets (+56.4%)  were the darlings of the last 5 year period while Perth and Darwin were still smarting from the fallout after the mining boom.

And once again the capital cities markets outperformed regional property, reflecting the strong economic and population trends of the current times.

Also read: Here’s why the Aussie dollar is down again

Interestingly, unlike previous cycles which were brought to a halt by rising interest rates, this market slowdown has been caused by a “credit squeeze” – the lack of availability of finance, particularly for investors following APRA’s introduction of macroprudential controls over the last few years.

Yardney 30/07/18

Source: Corelogic

What’s ahead?  

While most real estate investors worry about the value of their properties today, particularly in light of our falling property values in some of our cities, in my mind a much better question would be “where will property prices be 5 years or 20 years from now?”

And the good news is history suggests that the value of well-located capital city properties will continue to increase in value driven by our rising population and the wealth of our nation.

Michael Yardney is a director of Metropole Property Strategists, which creates wealth for its clients through independent, unbiased property advice and advocacy. He is a best-selling author, one of Australia’s leading experts in wealth creation through property and writes the Property Update blog.